Fiona Apple has been one of my favorite musicians for my entire adult life now. I feel connected to her music and lyrics to an extent that I only ever felt about Elliott Smith’s music.
She makes me feel so much less alone and her songs have helped me through almost every single heartbreak and pain I ever experienced in the last 10 years. Also she’s objectively a genius, both in musical talent and writing abilities.
Her choice of using such an extensive vocabulary with lots of very obscure words for most of her lyrics gives it kind of the feel of having to decipher a riddle she put out for only those who really want to put in the effort to understand her. I find that really endearing and interesting. I also love her in interviews.
She’s just extremely smart and so cool and original.
My ranking of her albums (at this point) would be:
1. The Idler Wheel… (2012)
2. When the Pawn… (1999)
3. Extraordinary Machine (2005) (I prefer the original leaked version where Jon Brion did the production)
4. Fetch the Bolt Cutters (2020)
5. Tidal (1996)
Also, fun fact: ever since I switched to streaming (a couple of years ago) every single year my recap has Elliott Smith on no. 1 of the most listened to artists. Most of the rest differs from year to year. But Fiona Apple is the only one besides him who is also always in one of my top spots.
ALSO: shout out to my friend who asked me for my top Fiona Apple song recommendations two days ago. You kind of inspired this list. <3
- Paper Bag
One of the most perfect songs to have ever been recorded.
I have never not felt like this. Every single line.
Possibly my favorite line is: “He said: It’s all in your head. And I said: So is everything. But he didn’t get it.” - Fast as you can
There is a live version of this from the early 2000s, recorded at Club Largo. It’s Fiona singing, Jon Brion on guitar and a crazy talented mandolin player who kills it so hard. I love that version at least as much as the original recording. Highly recommend!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IQfb9pY9fy4 - Periphery
This is my go-to song for when I’m a little bitter and feel mistreated and jealous of other people’s happiness in relationships.
One of my favorite lines is “I don’t appreciate people who don’t appreciate.” I think it’s a great guideline for navigating social interaction. - Anything we want
A perfect love song. Listening to it makes me really happy. Also I love that it’s not dramatic and full of big declarations. It’s just about some sweet gentle moments with another person. So it can fit basically any romantic situation. - Oh Well (Jon Brion production version)
This is song is sooo tragic. The back story is that it was written about her boyfriend (rumored to be PTA) cheating on her with some upcoming actress.
My favorite lines are:
“When I was looking with calm affection
You were searching out my imperfections” - I know
If you want to experience endless empathy and love for Fiona Apple watch her facial expressions in this live recording.
I am obsessed with it. She’s so perfect and beautiful.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yAcaUtlj8NE - Left Alone
My favorite lines are:
“It hurt more than it ought to hurt
I went to work to cultivate a callus”
and also
“My ills are reticulate
My woes are granular
The ants weigh more than the elephants” - Every Single Night
The anthem the overthinking overfeeling insomniac community needed and deserved. - A Mistake
I always feel like a bit naughty and femme fatale-y when listening to this song. It’s the kind of song you put on before willingly fucking up your life a little and I love it for that. We need songs like that. They are like your unhinged friends who encourage you to drunkenly text your toxic ex from years ago. - Valentine
This was the first song of hers I ever put on one of my mixes. Today I probably wouldn’t do that because even though I still love it and find it somewhat relatable, it doesn’t give off of a vibe I want to project anymore. Especially because of the references to self harm. The whole song is so deeply tragic and hopeless and even though I still feel like a fuck-up and loser when it comes to love and relationships most of the time, I don’t think I’m hopeless and destined to stay the person I once was or even am now.
I’m doing so much better these days and I hope one day in the future will come where I can’t relate to this song at all.
Honorary Mentions:
The Way Things Are
Heavy Balloon
Not About Love (Jon Brion production version)
Get Gone
Jonathan
Daredevil
Werewolf
Regret
Love Ridden
Fetch the Bolt Cutters
Under the Table